The next basic income test should start where the first one did

Mincome II would return to Dauphin and add a basic income bridge in Winnipeg for workers caught in the AI shift.

By
Spencer Fernando
UBI Works
|
November 19, 2026
|
-
Downtown Winnipeg in winter.
Winnipeg, Manitoba. Photo by Quintin Soloviev via Wikimedia Commons (CC0).

In this article

Spencer Fernando is a writer from Winnipeg whose work has appeared in the Winnipeg Sun and The Hub. Follow him on X and Substack.

The pace of change driven by artificial intelligence can seem bewildering and impossible to keep up with. Between predictions of a post-scarcity world and a world where nobody aside from a select few has a job, it’s difficult to know whether we are heading for something like a utopian future where we are freed from many of our present economic challenges, or a dystopian future of rampant inequality.

We are not simply helpless observers here. We are part of shaping what kind of future gets built. Our actions matter. Both a utopia and a dystopia are possible, and we can help shift the odds in either direction.

Now, I’m guessing we agree that the utopian future would be preferable. But what would that look like?

In Star Trek: First Contact, Captain Jean-Luc Picard said “the economics of the future is somewhat different,” adding “The acquisition of wealth is no longer the driving force in our lives. We work to better ourselves and the rest of humanity.”

Star Trek offers a vision of a post-scarcity society where technology has made it incredibly easy to satisfy most material needs, freeing people to pursue their own vision of flourishing. While that level of post-scarcity can seem far removed from our current lives, many aspects of our lives would look profoundly utopian from the perspective of someone living even 100 years ago. And that’s before considering how AI, self-driving vehicles, and widespread automation are accelerating the pace of change.

None of this is to dismiss the real struggles many people are experiencing. It’s clear that aspects of our economic systems will have to change (perhaps quite profoundly) as AI and automation play a larger role in our lives. Even as we acknowledge that, however, we can recognize that we have a strong foundation to build from, and that we can aspire to a world where our overriding concern can be bettering ourselves and the rest of humanity.

A hopeful problem to have

One thing you’ll notice about both the AI/automation-driven dystopian and utopian visions of the future is that neither presumes a scarcity of production. Both take for granted the idea that we are going to be able to produce a lot more with less human effort. The divergence is about distribution.

In a way, this is a hopeful problem to have. It took a long time for humanity to get to the point where one of our biggest problems could be about how to share what we produce, rather than just trying to eke out a meagre subsistence living in a harsh world.

By a rough estimate, output per hour worked was about C$1.75 in 1700, C$3.75 in 1900, and C$33 in 2025. Since 1900, output per hour worked outpaced output per person, as hours worked went down. That right there is a part of the shift towards a post-scarcity society, and a reason to be hopeful. As human civilization accumulates knowledge and becomes more efficient (which AI and automation both help with) we can produce more with less effort.

With that in mind, a Universal Basic Income (UBI) can play an important role in bringing a better world into being.

Because more productivity means a larger overall pool to draw from when considering measures to help provide people with a strong baseline standard of living, a UBI becomes increasingly feasible as time goes on. Even if we assume for a moment that AI and automation eliminate most jobs, there will still be more overall productivity and value generation. We can imagine an expanded Canada Strong Fund, investing in AI, robotics, nuclear power generation, computing, and more, with every citizen holding a share. Dividends from that fund, combined with a universal benefit, could ensure a dystopian scenario does not come to pass.

And in what I see as the much more likely event of the job market becoming more high-level and abstract rather than jobs disappearing, a UBI would help people navigate a much more fluid economic environment.

Further, by freeing people from desperation and exploitation, we can make it easier for people to engage in long-term planning, build families, and enrich themselves and others.

I firmly believe this is possible. And there are steps we can take right now. One such step would be to launch Mincome II, which I first proposed in the Winnipeg Sun.

Building on Dauphin

‘Mincome’ (short for minimum income) was a program launched in Manitoba in the 1970s. Best known for Dauphin, where every resident was eligible, it provided participants with a guaranteed income, but was wound down without a final report amid inflation and changes of government. Economist Evelyn Forget’s work showed that hospital admissions declined, and children were more likely to finish high school. Research on work rates also found a small drop.

The idea for Mincome II is that Manitoba should build on its history with testing out a UBI, this time with a firm commitment to collecting and analyzing the data immediately as it comes in, something that AI makes much more viable.

How Mincome II would work

The program would run in Dauphin and the surrounding rural municipality, with about 10,500 people, where the whole community would once again be covered, with every working-age resident eligible. There would also be a randomized trial of 1,500 low-income Winnipeg households that would be measured against 1,500 controls.

In a test of how a UBI could serve as an important ‘bridge’ at a time of possible AI disruption of the job market, a ‘bridge’ arm of 1,000 Winnipeggers would be compared with 1,000 controls. That group would cover people who recently lost a job, and young adults struggling to land their first job. This is based on early Bank of Canada evidence that people in AI-exposed professions are having a harder time finding work. People in the bridge program would get up to three years of income plus a $5,000 account for training, credentials or starting a business.

The benefit would be set as a floor at 75 per cent of the official poverty line, roughly $21,500 a year for a single adult in Dauphin and $30,400 for a couple. Each dollar earned would reduce the benefit by 50 cents, so working more always leaves people further ahead. The Winnipeg group would test a reduction of 40 cents for every dollar earned.

The benefit would be paid monthly through the tax system. There would be no caseworkers and no job-search rules. Child and disability benefits would be unchanged, and anyone moving off welfare would be guaranteed at least what they received before, so nobody is left worse off.

The program would run for five years, with payments starting in 2028, then a six-month tapering off period at the end.

The program would be built to survive elections, with the full budget put into a trust at launch, and participants’ terms written into law. Evaluation would be independent, with results published every year.

Evaluation would measure work and hours, how soon displaced workers found new jobs, worker retraining uptake, hospital use, and whether rent rises to swallow the benefit.

What it would cost

By my rough estimate, the base cost would be about $285 million over six years, and about $230 million after welfare savings are taken into consideration. The federal government would cover 75 per cent, as it did in the original Mincome program. Manitoba’s share would be about $10 million a year, less than four cents of every $100 the province spends.

At the same time, other parts of Canada should run different UBI test programs, with all information gathered and analyzed at the national level and shared with the public on a consistent basis.

We are at a moment of profound change. Let’s make the most of it, turn it into an opportunity, and start gathering the information we need to build an economy that works for everyone. Let’s get moving on Mincome II as soon as possible.

No items found.
Share this article

Share this article

Follow Us Online

Be Part of a Growing National Movement

Join 100,000+ Canadians Supporting Basic Income

Receive updates from UBI Works straight to your inbox.
Thank you!
Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Subscribe to UBI Works newsletter

Thanks for your submission.
Follow us on social media to join the discussion!
60K Likes
20K Followers
4K Followers
5K Subscribers
18K Followers
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.